Getting results since 1978

An appellate court remains an option after losing an initial trial

On Behalf of | Dec 8, 2021 | Appeals

A civil judgment could prove financially disastrous for a defendant in a lawsuit. The defendant might feel wronged by the decision, and there could be a credible, legal basis for challenging the outcome. Pursuing further action in a New York appellate court may provide a better and fairer result. Those wishing to appeal will need to follow the appropriate legal steps.

Taking action to appeal a court decision

All court decisions may undergo a review by an appeals court. Such is the case with federal and state court decisions, and administrative decisions state and federal agencies enact. Those who request appeals often attempt to show where the lower court made a mistake in its ruling.

For example, the lower court may rule the police had probable cause to make an arrest, but the appeals court could feel the lower court was mistaken. With a civil judgment, the appeals court might discover a witness lied or evidence turned out to be suppressed. Such scenarios may lead to the appeals court overturning a decision.

The appeals process is different

The appeals process is different from the initial trial. Among the starkest differences is the lack of a jury. With an appeal, the parties appear before a panel of judges. New evidence is commonly not presented, as the judges review what took place during the initial trial.

A written appellate brief presents the central argument for the appeal, and attorneys argue the merits of the briefs filed. Even if an appeal does not go the way someone wants, further options could be worth exploring.